Jammu:The High Court of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh has referred a crucial legal question concerning the challenge to Magistrates’ orders directing registration of FIRs to the Chief Justice for consideration by a larger Bench, following conflicting judicial views on the issue.
Justice Sanjay Parihar, while hearing two connected petitions involving senior police officials and a property dispute in Bishnah, observed that the revisability of orders passed under Section 156(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) requires an authoritative determination.
The Court directed the Registry to place the records of CRM(M) No. 678/2021 and CRM(M) No. 179/2025 before the Chief Justice for appropriate orders regarding the constitution of a larger Bench.
The central question is whether a Magistrate’s order directing registration of an FIR and police investigation is an interlocutory order, against which criminal revision is barred under Section 397(2) CrPC, or an intermediate order that can be challenged before a revisional court.
The first petition was filed by then SSP Jammu Shridhar Patil, then DSP Cyber Crime Parupkar Singh and then SHO Janipur Naresh Kumar, challenging a direction for registration of an FIR against police officials in a case involving Neha Chawla.
The connected petition was filed by Bharat Bhushan and Anuj Sajgotra against Neelam Gorkha over a dispute concerning National Medical Hall near Sub-District Hospital, Bishnah. In this case, the Additional Sessions Judge, Jammu, had dismissed their revision petition on February 28, 2025, holding that an order directing FIR registration was interlocutory and not revisable.
Justice Parihar referred to conflicting judicial precedents, including the Allahabad High Court’s Full Bench judgment in Father Thomas v. State of Uttar Pradesh and the High Court’s earlier ruling in Satpal Sharma v. Pawan Singh Rathore.
The Court also emphasised that Magistrates cannot act merely as forwarding authorities while directing police investigation. They must independently examine the allegations, supporting material and applicable statutory requirements before passing an order under Section 156(3) CrPC.
Observing that FIR registration and subsequent investigation can have serious implications for an individual’s liberty, reputation and privacy, the Court said such directions require proper judicial application of mind. It also clarified that prior sanction is not invariably required for every investigation against a police officer.
Justice Parihar framed six legal questions for consideration by the proposed larger Bench, including whether orders directing FIR registration are necessarily interlocutory, whether they can be challenged on grounds of lack of jurisdiction or non-application of judicial mind, and the scope of revisional interference.
The reference also covers corresponding provisions under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), particularly Sections 175(3) and 438(2).
The High Court has not finally decided whether such Magistrate-ordered FIR directions are revisable. The question will now be considered by the proposed larger Bench.
The judgment was pronounced on November 17, 2026. (JNF)
